HONEY BUTTER FUDGE RECIPE 1 cup Sugar 1 cup Brown Sugar 1/4 cup Butter 2 tbsp Honey 1/2 cup Evaporated milk 1/2 tsp Vanilla Mix first 5 ingredients in a saucepan. Stir constantly until mixture boils. Boil with stirring for about 7 min., or to the soft ball stage: 250 °F. Cool pan slightly in a dish of cold water. Add vanilla and beat until creamy. Scrape into a 7" X 7" pan. Mark into 36 squares and cool overnight. Cut fudge into pieces and separate to dry slightly.